Skip to main content

Air Quality: TVA Plans to Reduce Air Emissions Further, but Could Do More to Reduce Power Demand

GAO-02-301 Published: Mar 08, 2002. Publicly Released: Mar 22, 2002.
Jump To:
Skip to Highlights

Highlights

The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) relied on its 11 coal-burning plants to supply 60 percent of its electric power in fiscal year 2001. These plants account for almost all of TVA's emissions of two key air pollutants--sulfur dioxide (SO2), which has been linked to reduced visibility, and nitrogen oxides (NOx), which contribute to the formation of harmful ozone. To meet an increase in demand of 1.7 percent annually through 2010, TVA estimates that it will need to expand its current generating capacity of 30,365 megawatts by 500 megawatts annually. Building new generating capacity can produce more emissions, which raises environment concerns. To lessen the need for new capacity, TVA and other electricity suppliers promote the efficient use of electricity through "demand-side management" programs, which seek to reduce the amount of energy consumed or to change the time of day when it is consumed. Even though TVA intends to increase its capacity to generate electricity through 2005, it also expects to reduce its SO2 and NOx emissions during the same time period, primarily by burning lower-sulfur coal, installing devices to control emissions at its existing plants, and relying on fuels other than coal for new capacity. Although TVA's demand-side management programs have allowed customers to cut their electrical consumption, these programs have made only modest contributions to reducing peak-time demand. TVA has limited the scope of its key program to reduce peak-time consumption by residential customers because TVA believes the program is not cost-effective. TVA projects that its demand-side programs will produce nearly twice as much in savings between 2001 and 2005 as was achieved in the previous five years. Other large utilities have more fully implemented the types of programs that TVA now has in place and have also implemented a greater array of demand-side management tools. These programs have involved a much higher proportion of their residential customers and established different prices for electricity used during different times of the day.

Recommendations

Recommendations for Executive Action

Agency Affected Recommendation Status
Tennessee Valley Authority The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) should reevaluate the design of its current programs and evaluate opportunities for adopting proven ideas from other utilities. Accordingly, the TVA Chairman should evaluate the structure and effectiveness of its current programs.
Closed – Implemented
Interviewed responsible TVA staff regarding recommendation follow-up on 05/12/06. We were informed that, in the spring of 2005, TVA established an internal working group to review current and potential demand-side management and energy-efficiency programs and activities within the agency. We were told the group is currently reviewing active TVA programs and pilots as well as industry best practices.
Tennessee Valley Authority TVA should reevaluate the design of its current programs and evaluate opportunities for adopting proven ideas from other utilities. Accordingly, the TVA Chairman should review the longer-term potential applicability of other programs to its power system.
Closed – Implemented
See write-up for prior recommendation.
Tennessee Valley Authority TVA should reevaluate the design of its current programs and evaluate opportunities for adopting proven ideas from other utilities. Accordingly, the TVA Chairman should, as appropriate, implement demand-side management practices.
Closed – Implemented
See write-up for first recommendation.

Full Report

Office of Public Affairs

Topics

Air pollution controlElectric powerplantsEnergy consumptionEnergy demandEnergy suppliesEnvironmental monitoringOzoneSulfur dioxideCoalPlants